On the Confederate side, Jackson downplayed the battle because of his dissatisfaction with
the performance of
his troops. There is no doubt that Jackson didn't
want to highlight a battle where Union forces not only surprised him,
but also pinned his army down while Pope escaped.
Jackson must have also discovered that he outnumbered his Union attackers
three to one. For Stonewall Jackson to realize he held superior
defensive positions on high ground and that the under strength Union
forces were still able to break through the center of his line, must have been
a bitter pill to swallow.
Some of the other circumstances that contributed to the
poor documentation were...
- The low morale of the enlisted men and officers after the
Union defeat at Second Manassas.
Many of the surviving unit commanders never bothered to file required
after-action reports.
- Confusion over where the battle was fought.
The fact that the battle was initially called the Battle of Chantilly, a
name that persisted until present day, shows how the Union Commanders
were unaware of their location. In 1862 the area referred to as
Chantilly was well in the rear of Jackson's army. The battle was
actually fought on the south slope of Ox Hill as Jackson was attempting to outflank
Pope by advancing
on the crossroads at Germantown.